Get FREE, fast, and discreet delivery on any order anywhere in Canada! Review any product on our site & get 15% OFF your order!

Come As You Are Logo

Search Our Site

Come As You Are
Co-operative
(416) 760-7934
legend

on sale sex toys on sale sex toys

anal compatible sex toys anal compatible sex toys

strap-on compatible sex toys strap-on compatible sex toys

waterproof sex toys waterproof sex toys

sex toy staff picks sex toy staff picks

best selling sex toys best selling sex toys

sex toys made in canada sex toys made in canada

phthalate-free sex toys phthalate-free sex toys

A note on dimensions:
Length is listed first, then diameter. All measurements are in inches and are approximate. If the toy has an insertable portion, only the insertable portion's measurements are listed here.

subscribe to our newsletter!

gift cards | culture | press and media | donations | français

silicone butt plugs

Butt plugs offer an intense sensation of fullness and pressure. All our butt plugs are made from silicone and designed to stay in place during solo or partner sex play.  Learn how to choose a butt plug, use a butt plug, or clean a butt plug.

Unicorn Tail Plug
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
new sex toy Unicorn Tail Plug
A unicorn tail? Ack! We always figured we’d eventually find a puppy, bunny, or fox tail to offer our customers – never did we dream of a unicorn! Made with faux hair (no unicorns were harmed in the making of this tail), this toy features a lustrous, shiny tail attached to a silicone butt plug. Too p ... (read more) (3" x 1 1/4")

Read more about Unicorn Tail Plug.

$30.00 CAD

Aneros DeVice Prostate Massager
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys staff pick sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Aneros DeVice Prostate Massager
We can all agree - the Aneros Vice is a sexy toy. So is the Aneros Progasm. But, the Progasm is very firm, since it's made of hard plastic. And, the Vice has a vibrator in it, makin ... (read more) (4" x 1 1/4")

Read more about Aneros DeVice Prostate Massager.

$78.00 CAD

Aneros Eupho Syn Prostate Massager
waterproof sex toys staff pick sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Aneros Eupho Syn Prostate Massager
A little narrower than the Aneros Helix Syn, this silicone and plastic anal massager by Aneros is a good option for folks looking into Aneros prostate m ... (read more) (4" x 7/8")

Read more about Aneros Eupho Syn Prostate Massager.

$78.00 CAD

BSisNice Capsula Plug
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
BSisNice Capsula Plug
There's something profound about these prostate plugs from BSisNice. Fun without being funny, and playful without pretence, the Capsula butt plug is this little marvel of design that brings both physical and visual pleasure to every encounter. Whether the Capsula will cure what ails you, is anothe ... (read more) (3 1/4" x 1 1/4")

Read more about BSisNice Capsula Plug.

$52.00 CAD

BSisNice Tente Plug Large
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
BSisNice Tente Plug Large
With two sizes and two colours to choose from, the Tente plug from BSisNice has something for everyone. With a smooth silicone exterior, and a density with just the right amount of firmness and give, these butt plugs are perfect for prostate play, and all kinds of anal adventure. Handmade in Spain ... (read more) (2 3/4" x 1 1/4")

Read more about BSisNice Tente Plug Large.

$45.00 CAD

BSisNice Tente Plug Small
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
BSisNice Tente Plug Small
We've been having a long-distance relationship with these smart Spanish plugs for months now, and we thought it was finally time to take things to the next level. BSisNice's penultimate prostate plug comes in two sizes - perfect for anyone looking to expand their anal horizons, and for folks just s ... (read more) (2" x 1 1/4")

Read more about BSisNice Tente Plug Small.

$38.00 CAD

Buzz Vibrating Plug
waterproof sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Buzz Vibrating Plug
This hot pink number goes with every occasion! Ten settings, textured silicone, and a waterproof design makes this anal vibrator a great choice for those looking for a toy that is not too wide, but has some great options! Not quite a butt plug, this toy won't stay inside the body like the Pandora or ... (read more) (3" x 1")

Read more about Buzz Vibrating Plug.

$30.00 CAD

Fun Factory Bootie Small
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fun Factory Bootie Small
This perfect stay-put butt plug from Fun Factory will give you ample reason to shake your bootie! Made from easy-to-clean silicone, Bootie features an oblong base to fit snugly between your cheeks, a ... (read more) (1 1/2" x 3/4")

Read more about Fun Factory Bootie Small.

$45.00 CAD

Fuze Arrow
anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fuze Arrow
Like Cupid's arrow, but better! The Fuze Arrow won't just make you fall in love, it can also bring a new level of intensity to that love! The Arrow has that classic slimline butt plug design, but a few subtle modifications improve on this design significantly. Not only are all Fuze plugs made of ... (read more) (3" x 1")

Read more about Fuze Arrow.

$24.00 CAD

Fuze Hero
anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fuze Hero
We've always believed that sex toys could save the world, and maybe all we needed was a true sex toy super hero! Could Fuze's Hero be the one? Made of soft, but durable hypoallergenic silicone, the Fuze Hero has a good bulb-to-stem ratio to help keep it where you want it, and is compatible with yo ... (read more) (4" x 11/2")

Read more about Fuze Hero.

$32.00 CAD

Fuze Pace
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fuze Pace
Fuze has really hit their stride with the Pace. The Fuze Pace features two anal compatible ends, either of which can be enjoyed for anal play or prostate massage. One end features a smooth shaft with a slight bulb at the end. The other features a beautiful anal bead design. With space for a bullet v ... (read more) (4" x 1 1/8")

Read more about Fuze Pace.

$40.00 CAD

Fuze Pleasure Plug Four
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fuze Pleasure Plug Four
One, two buckle my shoe. Three, four open the door to an anal sex adventure to remember! Made from sensuous silicone, the Fuze Pleasure Plug Four is the largest in the Fuze Pleasure Plug Series and the most ambitious one to date! Design ... (read more) (5 1/4" x 1 1/2")

Read more about Fuze Pleasure Plug Four.

$45.00 CAD

Fuze Pleasure Plug One
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fuze Pleasure Plug One
There's little that pleases us more than a classic sex toy reimagined for the kinds of sex that people actually have, not some ill-informed or antiquated idea of sex that is reflected in the vinyl butt plugs of yesteryear. The brainchild of Peterborough-based read more) (4" x 7/8")

Read more about Fuze Pleasure Plug One.

$20.00 CAD

Fuze Pleasure Plug Three
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fuze Pleasure Plug Three
If the Happy Valley Pleasure Plug was an homage to the sad vinyl plugs of the 70s and 80s, then this series of Fuze Pleasure Plugs is the perfect tribute to the butt plugs of the aughts. With the same classic butt plug design you've known ... (read more) (4 3/4" x 1 3/8")

Read more about Fuze Pleasure Plug Three.

$35.00 CAD

Fuze Pleasure Plug Two
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fuze Pleasure Plug Two
The second instalment in the Fuze Silicone Pleasure Plug series is the wonderful Fuze Pleasure Plug Two. Not too big, not too small, just the perfect silicone plug for when you're in the mood for something a little more advanced than the ... (read more) (4 1/2" x 1 1/4")

Read more about Fuze Pleasure Plug Two.

$23.00 CAD

Fuze Sol
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fuze Sol
It is a butt plug bonanza from our friends at Happy Valley! The Fuze Sol will bring a little sunshine to where the sun don't shine and because it is made of hypoallergenic and boil-able silicone, with a little cleaning, you can even share the Sol with someone! As with all Fuze anal toys, the handy ... (read more) (4" x 1 1/4")

Read more about Fuze Sol.

$24.00 CAD

Fuze Whirl
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fuze Whirl
With a great bulb-to-stem ratio for awesome stay-putted-ness, The Fuze Whirl is a silicone butt plug with a litte something extra! The Whirl features ridges through the toy's bulb for a more textured experience. Not only are all Fuze plugs made of hypoallergenic silicone, but their handy-dandy bas ... (read more) (3 1/2" x 1 1/4")

Read more about Fuze Whirl.

$24.00 CAD

Fuze Zone
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys best selling sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fuze Zone
Featuring smooth lines, sumptuous silicone, and the quality that always comes with Fuze toys, this clever design allows for different uses of this toy! The Zone is designed to be anal compatible, where either end of this toy can be inserted in the body for bum play or prostate massage! With space fo ... (read more) (4" x 1 1/8")

Read more about Fuze Zone.

$40.00 CAD

Happy Valley Pip Plug
anal compatible sex toys sex toys made in canada phthalate-free sex toys
Happy Valley Pip Plug
This charming butt plug from Happy Valley is smooth, slender and made of silicone. With a good bulb-to-stem ratio, Happy Valley's Pip plug stays in place nicely when in use, and Pip's curvy bulbous end hits all of the right spots. This smaller plug is great for folks just starting out in anal play ... (read more) (3 1/2" x 3/4")

Read more about Happy Valley Pip Plug.

$17.00 CAD

Hole Punch Toys Ass Cram Cone
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Hole Punch Toys Ass Cram Cone
*LARGE* tri-color silicone butt plug, or dildo. Not for the faint of...uh...heart. Handmade with a soft & squishy silicone in the USA. Available online only! (5" x 2")

Read more about Hole Punch Toys Ass Cram Cone.

$104.00 CAD

Hole Punch Toys Plugs Bunny
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Hole Punch Toys Plugs Bunny
"Why did the carrot win an award? Because it was out-standing in it's field...!" *crickets*

This is one of the few carrots that we can enthusiastically stamp with the 'stick it in your butt' seal of approval. With lots of lovely bumpy carrot-y ridges, and a lush n' leafy flared base, this handm ... (read more) (4 3/4" x 1 1/4")

Read more about Hole Punch Toys Plugs Bunny.

$85.00 CAD

Hole Punch Toys Pocket Rocket
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Hole Punch Toys Pocket Rocket
Imagine the world famous Hole Punch Crotch Rocket flew through a wormhole into a parallel universe where it emerged at a fraction of it's original size trailing a pearl white cloud of smoke and landed right in your butt... Now put down the bong and wake up. It's real.

Available online only. (4" x 1 1/2")

Read more about Hole Punch Toys Pocket Rocket.

$87.00 CAD

Hole Punch Toys Rad-ish
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Hole Punch Toys Rad-ish
This is a radish. For your butt. What could be better?!

But, seriously: everyone into the slow and homegrown food movements, look no further for your next butt plug! Rad-Ish features a firm and bulbous (rad-ish-y) head, and generous (leaf-y) flare to avoid getting planted too deeply in butts. Th ... (read more) (3" x 1 3/8")

Read more about Hole Punch Toys Rad-ish.

$89.00 CAD

Hole Punch Toys The Hole Punch
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Hole Punch Toys The Hole Punch
Hole Punch's signature butt plug - hand sculpted in the USA! Available online only. (3 1/2" x 1 3/8")

Read more about Hole Punch Toys The Hole Punch.

$28.00 CAD

Renegade Anal Trainer Kit
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Renegade Anal Trainer Kit
This three-piece kit is a great grab-n-go for the enthusiast with big butt plug plans for an ass they know or love! This kit features three differently sized anal plugs with suction cup bases. While they may not be made with the same exacting standards as the gauged Pleasure Plugs by Fuze, they are ... (read more)

Read more about Renegade Anal Trainer Kit.

$50.00 CAD

Renegade Vibrating Tail
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Renegade Vibrating Tail
This vibrating butt plug has been endowed with a generous handle, which does lend it a tail-like look. Girthy and rumbly, this waterproof vibrating anal toy also looks amazingly like the Statue of Liberty's torch when, um, not in a bum. (4 1/2" x 2")

Read more about Renegade Vibrating Tail.

$52.00 CAD

Rocks Off Bad Boy
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Rocks Off Bad Boy
If you were one of those guys who just wanted more from your Rude Boy, the Bad Boy offers a bigger and more bulbous shaft for advanced players and size queens alike. This butt plug has all of the vibration of the original Rude Boy, yet gives a more intense and full experience. With a thick shaft th ... (read more) (5" x 1 3/4")

Read more about Rocks Off Bad Boy.

$90.00 CAD

Tantus Prostate Play Vibrator
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Tantus Prostate Play Vibrator
The curved shape of this silicone anal toy has been designed with prostates in mind, but, hey, g-spots also sometimes love vibrations through the anal wall! Regardless, this toy vibrates thanks to an (included) removable bullet - pull it out to boil the toy, or enjoy as a separate buzzy sex toy. Cur ... (read more) (4 1/4" x 1 1/4")

Read more about Tantus Prostate Play Vibrator.

$100.00 CAD

Vibratex Black Pearl
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Vibratex Black Pearl
The amazing folks who make the Magic Wand, Rabbit Habit and Pandora have now released a rechargeable anal toy! The Black Pe ... (read more) (3 3/4" x 1")

Read more about Vibratex Black Pearl.

$105.00 CAD

Fuze Halo
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Fuze Halo
With a great bulb-to-stem ratio for awesome stay-putted-ness, The Fuze Halo is a larger version of the Fuze Whirl. The Halo features ridges through the toy's bulb for a more textured experience. Not only are all Fuze butt plugs made of hypoallergeni ... (read more) (4" x 1 1/2") This item is currently out of stock

Read more about Fuze Halo.

$32.00 CAD

Happy Valley Ergo Plug
anal compatible sex toys sex toys made in canada phthalate-free sex toys
Happy Valley Ergo Plug
Get into anal play the ERGOnomic way with the Canadian-made Ergo butt plug! With the perfect curve for prostate play (or g-spot - just remember to boil between uses!), Happy Valley's silicone Ergo plug represents the natural evolution of the Pleasure Plug series. Slender and smooth and perfect for ... (read more) (3 1/2" x 1") This item is currently out of stock

Read more about Happy Valley Ergo Plug.

$18.00 CAD

Happy Valley Little Snoop
strap-on compatible sex toys anal compatible sex toys sex toys made in canada phthalate-free sex toys
Happy Valley Little Snoop
Our smallest little silicone toy, perfect for an evening of first-time anal exploration and prostate massage. About the size of a finger (or a little smaller), this easy-to-clean silicone anal dildo from Happy Valley is non-threatening and velvety smooth for sensual experimentation. (4 1/2" x 1") This item is currently out of stock

Read more about Happy Valley Little Snoop.

$30.00 CAD

Tantus B Bomb Anal Vibrator
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Tantus B Bomb Anal Vibrator
The B Bomb comes with a One-Touch Bullet that transforms this silicone anal plug into a vibrating anal toy! With smooth curving lines, and a waterproof design, B Bomb is a simple yet satisfying anal toy. (3 1/4" x 1 3/8") This item is currently out of stock

Read more about Tantus B Bomb Anal Vibrator.

$75.00 CAD

Vixen Tristan 1.5
waterproof sex toys anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Vixen Tristan 1.5
Dreaming of upgrading to the Vixen Tristan 2, but worried that your eyes may be bigger than your...? Play it safe (and sexy) with this still-substantial Tristan 1.5. Made by the good folks at Vixen in the USA, this soft silicone plug might just b ... (read more) (3 1/2" x 2") This item is currently out of stock

Read more about Vixen Tristan 1.5.

$62.00 CAD

Vixen Tristan 2
anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Vixen Tristan 2
Designed and inspired by the infamous Tristan Taormino, the Tristan 2 butt plug from Vixen Creations is even bigger tha ... (read more) (3 3/4" x 2 1/4") This item is currently out of stock

Read more about Vixen Tristan 2.

$69.00 CAD

Vixen Tristan
anal compatible sex toys phthalate-free sex toys
Vixen Tristan
This brilliant anal creation comes courtesy of the fine folks at Vixen Creations and the infamous anal player Tristan Taorm ... (read more) (3 1/8" x 1 1/2") This item is currently out of stock

Read more about Vixen Tristan.

$57.00 CAD

The Ultimate Guide to Anal Sex for Women
The Ultimate Guide to Anal Sex for Women
By Tristan Taormino
This friendly, forthright guide rips the lid off the myth that women don't enjoy anal sex. With quotes from erotic literature, real-life women, and fun illustrations, this guide covers all the bases, including anatomy, health and safety, emotional and psychological issues, toy ... (read more)

Read more about The Ultimate Guide to Anal Sex for Women.

$22.95 CAD

 

Come As You Are Co-op on Facebook  Come As You Are Co-op on Twitter  Come As You Are Co-op on Instagram  Come As You Are Co-op on Google  Come As You Are Co-op on Pinterest  Come As You Are Co-op on Tumblr  Come As You Are Co-op on Yelp

© 1997-2016 Come As You Are & CAYA Co-operative Ltd.