Get fast, discreet, and FREE DELIVERY in Canada on orders over $49 and USA orders over $149!



Silicone

Butt plugs are a great way to explore anal play! Designed to "stay put" whilst one enjoys other activities - sex, brunch, skype, whatever - butt plugs aren't usually toys you want to thrust in and out. Rather, allow the sphincter to close and relax around the stem of the plug, sit back, and enjoy the resultant feelings of fullness and pressure. The larger the bulb-to-stem ratio (the bigger the bulb, and the narrower the stem), the better the plug will stay in place during use. Looking for a plug for long term play? Try the Fun Factory Bootie series!
Length: 4.5"
Width: 1.25"

The second instalment in the Fuze Silicone Pleasure Plug series is the wonderful Fuze Pleasure Plug Two. Not too big, not too small, just the perfect silicone plug for when you're in the mood for something a little more advanced... Read more

Regular price $24.00
Length: 3"
Width: 1"

Like Cupid's arrow, but better! The Fuze Arrow won't just make you fall in love, it can also bring a new level of intensity to that love! The Arrow has that classic slimline butt plug design, but a few subtle... Read more

Regular price $22.00
Length: 4"
Width: 0.875"

There's little that pleases us more than a classic sex toy reimagined for the kinds of sex that people actually have, not some ill-informed or antiquated idea of sex that is reflected in the vinyl butt plugs of yesteryear. The... Read more

Regular price $21.00
Length: 4"
Width: 1.25"
Love our Fuze butt plugs, but want something that vibrates all the time? Well, how about a vibrating anal toy that has 10 settings, waterproof, and is full of fun? Look no further- This Rocket will take you to the... Read more
Regular price $30.00
Length: 3.25"
Width: 1.375"

As some of you may know, there's a way-too-long story to almost everything we talk about. And, the nerds that we are, we always think these stories are *so* exciting and interesting. We acknowledge that they might not be to... Read more

Regular price $31.00
Length: 4.75"
Width: 1.375"
If the Happy Valley Pleasure Plug was an homage to the sad vinyl plugs of the 70s and 80s, then this series of Fuze Pleasure Plugs is the perfect tribute to the butt plugs of the aughts. With the same... Read more
Regular price $35.00
Length: 1.5"
Width: 0.75"
This perfect stay-put butt plug from Fun Factory will give you ample reason to shake your bootie! Made from easy-to-clean silicone, Bootie features an oblong base to fit snugly between your cheeks, a bulbous tip for great anal and prostate... Read more
Regular price $45.00
Length: 4.5"
Width: 1.5"
Part of the same line as our Booty Blaster and Booty Beads, The Rider has stolen our cooperative hearts. This vibrating butt plug has 10 different settings, and is waterproof. It has been turning heads and breaking hearts with it's... Read more
Regular price $40.00

Ooh indeed! Collect them all, trade with friends, or grab a kit – these modular vibes are the shit! But, seriously, folks. We love the swap ‘em out nature of this line of toys by Je Joue. The Mini Motor... Read more

Regular price $80.00
Length: 3"
Width: 1.25"
Sometimes sex toy dreams really do come true - and this is one of those recurring dreams that just wouldn't materialize... until now! The We-Vibe Ditto is the perfect petite plug that lucid dreams are made of! With We-Vibe's extraordinarily... Read more
Regular price $132.00
Length: 3"
Width: 1.2"
Yet more tails from NS Novelties! This charming bunny tail is made with polyester fur, and a silicone plug. Perfect for all the sweet bunnies out there! Easily cleaned with soap and water. Read more
Regular price $23.00
Length: 3.75"
Width: 2.25"
Designed and inspired by the infamous Tristan Taormino, the Tristan 2 butt plug from Vixen Creations is even bigger than the original but has all of the stay-put goodness you've come to expect from Vixen. We're looking at you, seasoned... Read more
Regular price $65.00 Sold Out

This three-piece kit is a great grab-n-go for the enthusiast with big butt plug plans for an ass they know or love! This kit features three differently sized anal plugs with suction cup bases. While they may not be made... Read more

Regular price $42.00
Length: 5.25"
Width: 1.5"
One, two buckle my shoe. Three, four open the door to an anal sex adventure to remember! Made from sensuous silicone, the Fuze Pleasure Plug Four is the largest in the Fuze Pleasure Plug Series and the most ambitious one... Read more
Regular price $45.00
Insertable Length: 3"
Insertable Width: 1"

With a smooth silicone exterior, and a density with just the right amount of firmness and give, these classic butt plugs are perfect for all kinds of anal adventure. Each Unico plug design is completely one-of-a-kind - and handmade with love in... Read more

Regular price $55.00
Insertable Length: 3.5"
Insertable Width: 2"

Dreaming of upgrading to the Vixen Tristan 2, but worried that your eyes may be bigger than your...? Play it safe (and sexy) with this still-substantial Tristan 1.5. Made by the good folks at Vixen in the USA, this soft... Read more

Regular price $60.00 Sold Out
Length: 4"
Width: 1.5"

With a great bulb-to-stem ratio for awesome stay-putted-ness, The Fuze Halo is a larger version of the Fuze Whirl. The Halo features ridges through the toy's bulb for a more textured experience. Not only are all Fuze butt plugs made... Read more

Regular price $35.00
Length: 3.125"
Width: 1.5"
This brilliant anal creation comes courtesy of the fine folks at Vixen Creations and anal play sexpert Tristan Taormino. With a special base designed to keep your plug where you want it, Tristan's mushroom shaped plug also makes Tristan an... Read more
Regular price $55.00
Length: 3.5"
Width: 1.25"

This silicone sleeve is an exciting addition to Je Joue's line of Ooh modular vibes! Pair with Je Joue's Large Motor, and, voilà! Vibrator! Featuring a smooth curve often seen in other anal toys or prostate massagers, this bum-play-friendly toy... Read more

Regular price $39.00
Length: 3.5"
Width: 1.25"

With a great bulb-to-stem ratio for awesome stay-putted-ness, The Fuze Whirl is a silicone butt plug with a litte something extra! The Whirl features ridges through the toy's bulb for a more textured experience. Not only are all Fuze plugs... Read more

Regular price $26.00
Length: 4"
Width: 1.25"

It is a butt plug bonanza from our friends at Fuze! The Fuze Sol will bring a little sunshine to where the sun don't shine and because it is made of hypoallergenic and boil-able silicone, with a little cleaning, you... Read more

Regular price $24.00
Length: 4"
Width: 1.5"

We've always believed that sex toys could save the world, and maybe all we needed was a true sex toy super hero! Could Fuze's Hero be the one? Made of soft, but durable hypoallergenic silicone, the Fuze Hero has a... Read more

Regular price $35.00
Length: 3"
Width: 1"

This hot pink number goes with every occasion! Ten settings, textured silicone, and a waterproof design makes this anal vibrator a great choice for those looking for a toy that is not too wide, but has some great options! Not... Read more

Regular price $28.00
Length: 3.75"
Width: 1"
The amazing folks behind the Magic Wand Original, classic Rabbit Habit and Pandora have now released a rechargeable anal toy! The Black Pearl has been marketed as a prostate massager, but we find that bums belonging to many types of... Read more
Regular price $96.00
Length: 3"
Width: 1 3/8"
This is a radish. For your butt. What could be better?!

But, seriously: everyone into the slow and homegrown food movements, look no further for your next butt plug! Rad-Ish features a firm and bulbous (rad-ish-y) head, and generous (leaf-y)... Read more

Regular price $92.00 Sold Out
Length: 3"
Width: 7/8"
Baby carrots aren't just for dip platters anymore! Squeezing in at just under an inch wide, this butt plug is great for easing into snug... places. Smooth and tapered, with a flourish of leafy anal-compatible greens, this handmade toy may... Read more
Regular price $53.00 Sold Out
Insertable Length: 3"
Width: 1.25"
These playful long & lustrous tails are an exciting new addition to our tail collection at Come As You Are! Featuring a silicone plug with polyester hair, this toy is perfect for any pony play, role play, cosplay, or other... Read more
Regular price $28.00

From our favourite Tentacle Dildo maker, these gorgeous Rosebud Butt Plugs from our local silicone heros at LoveCrafters are soft, supple, and just about the most romantic butt plug we've ever encountered. They say every rose has its thorn, but... Read more

Regular price $75.00
Length: 4 3/4"
Width: 1 1/4"
"Why did the carrot win an award? Because it was out-standing in it's field...!" *crickets*

This is one of the few carrots that we can enthusiastically stamp with the 'stick it in your butt' seal of approval. With lots of... Read more

Regular price $88.00 Sold Out
Length: 3.5"
Width: 1.375"
Hole Punch's signature butt plug - hand sculpted in the USA! Read more
Regular price $28.00 Sold Out
Length: 5"
Width: 2"
This is a uh, LARGE tri-color silicone butt plug, or dildo. Not for the faint of...uh...heart. Handmade with a soft & squishy silicone in the USA. Read more
Regular price $106.00 Sold Out
Length: 2.25"
Width: 1.5"

The greatest, most tremendous thing to Put-in your butt. 

Read more
Regular price $70.00
Length: 2"
Width: 1.5"

Sometimes the sweetest fruits are the least anal-compatible, fortunately, this made-in-Canada glazed strawberry plug is here to bring all of your fruit-filled fantasies to life!

Read more
Regular price $81.00
Length: 2.5"

All of the cute and perfectly creepiness of the original LoveCrafters Tentacle Dildo now in a smaller, butt-appropriate-sized package! Ridiculously fun and perfect for fantasy play - and made in a fair wage environment right here in Canada! Can't get... Read more

Regular price $54.00
Whether you're looking to train your butt (or a butt you love) for bigger and bigger adventures, or you're a believer that variety is the spice of life, this kit lets you work your way up from the slim and... Read more
Regular price $130.00
Length: 3.75"
Width: 1.5"
Launch into orbit with this cheeky and innovative toy from Hole Punch! This artisanal modular rocket is 50% butt-plug, 50% penis sleeve... and 100% sex toy art! Handcrafted in the USA, this toy comes apart easily - after which, you... Read more
Sale price $74.00 Regular price $92.00 Sale
Length: 3"
Width: 1"

This amazingly adorable rainbow plug is the perfect combination of butt plug and anal beads! With waves of smooth silicone that get bigger the deeper you go, this is BSisNice at their best: functional, beautiful, and handmade in Spain -... Read more

Regular price $62.00
Length: 3"
Width: 1.25"

A unicorn tail? Ack! We always figured we’d eventually find a puppy, bunny, or fox tail to offer our customers – never did we dare dream of a unicorn! Made with faux hair (no unicorns were harmed in the making... Read more

Regular price $28.00
Length: 2.75"
Width: 1"

This silicone sleeve is an exciting addition to Je Joue's modular line of vibes! Pair with Je Joue's Mini Motor, and, voilà! Vibrator! Featuring a smooth curve often seen in other anal toys or prostate massagers, this bum-play-friendly toy is... Read more

Regular price $25.00
Length: 4"
Width: 1.125"

Featuring smooth lines, sumptuous silicone, and the quality that always comes with Fuze toys, this clever design allows for different uses of this toy! The Zone is designed to be anal compatible, where either end of this toy can be... Read more

Regular price $43.00
Length: 3"
Width: 1.125"
Maybe you love the petite original Bootie Small plug and you’re ready to size up, or maybe you’re looking for the not-too-big-or-too-small butt plug of your dreams. Either way, it's worth it to check out Fun Factory's Bootie Medium. Slip... Read more
Regular price $52.00
Length: 4"
Width: 1.375"
Maybe you love the intermediate Bootie Medium plug and you’re ready to size up, or maybe you’re looking for the sizeable butt plug of your dreams. Either way, it's worth it to check out Fun Factory's Bootie Large. Slip this... Read more
Regular price $60.00
Length: 2.75"
Width: 1.25"

The Tente plug from BSisNice has something for everyone. With a smooth silicone exterior, and a density with just the right amount of firmness and give, these butt plugs are perfect for prostate play, and all kinds of anal adventure.

... Read more
Regular price $45.00